Why did I feel it was interesting to interview Maeve? She is an American museum professional and cultural leader currently serving as the Executive Director of the Edgar Allan Poe Museum in Richmond, Virginia. In this role she oversees the museum’s operations, collections, public programming, and strategic development while guiding one of the world’s largest collections of artifacts related to Edgar Allan Poe. Her background spans nonprofit leadership, historic interpretation, fundraising, and public engagement in the museum sector. Since becoming director in the early 2020s, she has overseen institutional growth, expanded community partnerships, and helped modernize exhibitions while maintaining scholarly integrity and historical context. Under her leadership, the museum has strengthened its role as both a research center for Poe studies and an active cultural institution within Richmond’s artistic and educational communities.
The interview above is particularly interesting because it offers a rare inside perspective on how a literary museum operates in the twenty-first century. Rather than focusing only on Edgar Allan Poe’s legacy, Maeve discusses the practical and philosophical challenges of running a historic institution: balancing authenticity with innovation, engaging contemporary audiences, managing collections, and navigating sensitive historical topics. Her reflections also illuminate how museums today function not just as repositories of artifacts but as dynamic cultural spaces that connect scholarship, education, and community life. By combining personal background with institutional insight, the conversation reveals how modern museum leadership requires equal parts historical expertise, public communication, and strategic management.
Here’s our exchange:
Where are you originally from, and what aspects of your childhood there most shaped who you are today?
I grew up on a small farm in Clarke County, Virginia. Four generations of my family have lived on this farm. Clarke County is a rural community nestled in the beautiful Shenandoah Valley of the Blue Ridge Mountains. As a child, I spent most of my time outdoors with my two sisters, taking care of farm animals like rabbits and goats, or reading. It was an idyllic childhood in many ways, and in retrospect I am very grateful for the sense of belonging and identity that growing up in such a beautiful rural area gave me, as well as for the appreciation it fostered for my family’s history.
How would you describe your family environment growing up, and who were the most influential figures in your early life?
My immediate family operated as a very close unit during my childhood. I am the middle of three daughters, and we remain very close. My parents encouraged each of us to engage with the world through reading, play, and hobbies. They modeled the core values they instilled in us. My mother and father were certainly the most influential figures in my early life. They were physically and mentally active, took my sisters and me on wonderful trips, and maintained high standards for our performance in school and extracurricular activities.
Were there particular family or cultural traditions that played a lasting role in shaping your values or worldview?
My mother, in particular, has always been deeply committed to serving her community. She often brought my sisters and me along with her when she volunteered. She worked with refugees new to the area, volunteered at a literacy nonprofit, supported new mothers, and much more. She always expected her daughters to follow her lead. In retirement, she actually spends more time volunteering than ever. So a commitment to community service was instilled in me from the very beginning.
We were also a very busy family. I took dance classes, performed in school musicals, joined the debate team, showed animals at the county fair with my 4-H group, babysat, and more. There was definitely an expectation to stay busy and engaged. Although I sometimes remember wishing I could sleep in more, that culture of activity ultimately set me up well for college.
What initially drew you to the field you chose to study, and was there a moment when you realized it was the right path for you?
My father has always been an avid reader of Charles Dickens. I remember him reading Great Expectations to me when I was home sick with the flu at age ten. That moment ignited my early passion for literature, though at the time I never imagined it could lead to anything beyond personal enjoyment.
When I began my studies at the University of Virginia, I enrolled in as many literature courses as I could manage simply out of curiosity about the works I had grown up reading. Very quickly, I realized that literary studies was the field for me. It balances close reading with historical inquiry, critical thinking with contextual understanding—the hyperspecificity of a single novel with the broader aesthetic sensibility of an era. I was very fortunate at UVA to study under wonderful professors who encouraged me to continue my studies by completing a master’s degree within the department.
At what age did you begin working, and what did your first job teach you about responsibility or independence?
One of my first jobs was assisting the groundskeeper of the estate that surrounded my family’s farm. I was about ten or eleven during the first summer I worked with him. He put me to work on big, strenuous tasks like hacking down invasive ivy from a boxwood maze and mowing large stretches of lawn.
It was hard work, and I was often exhausted by the end of the day. But it was also the first time I was earning money through my own labor, and I remember feeling proud of the effort I put in each day. The job taught me accountability and reinforced the idea that a job done halfway is worse than a job never started.
How would you describe your current professional role, and what aspects of it do you find most meaningful?
I “wear many hats” as Executive Director at the Poe Museum. I am responsible for the successful operation of the museum, ensuring a positive experience for visitors, recruiting and managing a staff of eleven, and safeguarding both the institution’s collections and its financial health.
The breadth of responsibilities was daunting when I first accepted the role. Since then, however, the staff at the Poe Museum has grown into a high-achieving and close-knit team of remarkable individuals. Facilitating the development and success of my colleagues has become one of the most rewarding aspects of my work—something I did not anticipate when I began four years ago.
Ultimately, though, my favorite part of the role is engaging public audiences in conversations about history and literature. That is what drew me to museum work in the first place. Any opportunity to lead a tour or deliver a lecture about the museum and Edgar Allan Poe is a pleasure.
How do you balance staying true to Edgar Allan Poe’s complex literary legacy with the need to make the museum’s programming relevant and accessible to diverse contemporary audiences?
Fortunately, Poe remains one of the most enduring and widely read poets more than two centuries after his birth. That gives historians and educators many excellent entry points for engaging audiences.
One of the most effective approaches to historical interpretation is making it personal and relatable. When we talk about Poe, visitors often arrive having read “The Raven,” watched horror films, or listened to true crime podcasts. All of these can spark conversations about Poe’s influence and legacy. Once that connection is established, it becomes easier to explore the more complex aspects of his life and reputation.
For example, we might ask: How could Poe be one of the most popular writers of his era while also being dismissed by some contemporaries as “the jingle man”? What genres did he invent, refine, or critique? How has he remained both a canonical literary figure and a popular culture icon for nearly two hundred years?
As a nonprofit museum, we are committed to our mission—“illuminating Poe for everyone, evermore”—and to creating welcoming experiences for visitors of all backgrounds. Events such as UnHappy Hours, black cat adoption days, or free youth activity days help broaden access to the museum. Even during these more casual programs, we intentionally incorporate educational components. At our UnHappy Hours, for instance, our curator hosts a “Curator’s Crypt,” where visitors can examine themed objects from the collection under supervision. Poe’s wide-ranging interests and themes allow us to balance education and entertainment in creative ways.
The Poe Museum is rooted in a historic house but also houses one of the world’s largest collections of Poe artifacts. What are the biggest challenges in curating historical authenticity without letting the past overshadow innovation?
Museums must constantly navigate the balance between adopting new technologies and exhibit strategies while maintaining historical accuracy.
The Poe Museum’s campus includes four historic buildings, though only one—the Old Stone House, dating to the 1740s—is under a historic easement. This allows us some flexibility in exhibit design while still respecting the historical character of the space.
Importantly, the Poe Museum is not a traditional house museum. Poe never lived in the Old Stone House, and the interiors are not staged to represent a domestic residence. That distinction has given us more freedom to incorporate modern exhibit techniques without compromising the building’s integrity.
More broadly, museums risk stagnation if they fail to evolve alongside their audiences. Visitors today have more options than ever for how they spend their leisure time, and expectations for cultural institutions continue to change rapidly.
Edgar Allan Poe never lived in the actual buildings that now house the museum, yet the site is central to its identity. How do you navigate questions of authenticity when constructing narratives for visitors?
This is a common source of confusion for visitors, especially because many literary museums are located in the homes where authors once lived.
From the beginning of the tour, we clarify that Poe did not live on the museum grounds. Instead, we focus on the formative influence of his childhood in Richmond. We interpret the Old Stone House as an important historic structure in its own right—connected to the broader Richmond of Poe’s era—and we also explain how and why the museum itself was established, originally as the Poe Shrine, in Shockoe Bottom.
Similarly, when we use artifacts from Poe’s childhood in exhibit staging—such as our interpretation of his childhood bedroom featuring his bed and furniture from the Allan household—we emphasize that this is a reconstruction rather than the original space where he grew up. Interpretive text and visual cues help communicate this distinction. For instance, the modern wallpaper in the room features skulls, ravens, and the Poe Museum logo, signaling to visitors that the space is interpretive rather than authentic.
We are always careful not to create a misleading sense of historical authenticity.
As a nonprofit museum that relies heavily on donors and private collections, how do you maintain curatorial independence while cultivating relationships with major benefactors?
We are fortunate to have wonderful relationships with some of the preeminent collectors of Edgar Allan Poe, as well as a strong base of generous donors who support our mission. Like all museums, our commitment is to ethical and transparent curatorial processes. We rely on our Collections Management Policy to guide staff and maintain transparency with donors and audiences. This policy outlines everything from what kinds of donations we can accept, the process of acceptance—from committee approval to board approval—to the terms of loans and procedures for deaccessioning items.
I am proud that so many Poe collectors have trusted the museum with donations from their personal collections over the years. I believe this trust rests on the integrity of the museum and its team. Donors feel that the Poe Museum is the right place for their pieces to live, to be shared with the public, and to tell the story of Edgar Allan Poe. We take that responsibility very seriously.
The museum recently underwent exhibit redesigns and welcomed new board members bringing expertise in technology, education, and community outreach. What strategic changes are you pushing for, and where should traditional museums adapt more boldly?
The Poe Museum celebrated its centennial anniversary in 2022. In 2025, we completed a transformative redesign of our exhibit spaces. Attendance is now more than 35% above pre-pandemic records. This is a pivotal moment for the museum to take on a more prominent role both in its community and within the broader landscape of Poe studies. Our staff and board are currently working on our next strategic plan to ensure that we meet this opportunity with both care and boldness.
Our strategy is always guided by our audiences. We see sustained and growing interest in Edgar Allan Poe, and we are preparing to meet that interest with expanded programming, deeper community engagement, additional resources for scholars and educators, and stronger marketing.
One key to our recent success is that we have not been afraid to experiment—with new programs, different marketing approaches, and more—and equally unafraid to abandon initiatives that do not work. If a program fails to retain an audience, it should either change dramatically or disappear. It is easy for small nonprofits to rely on the same annual programming calendar year after year, but doing so can threaten both long-term audience engagement and institutional sustainability.
Richmond’s connection to Poe is historically significant yet sometimes overshadowed by broader narratives of American literature. How do you assert the city’s place in Poe’s life and work in ways that are both scholarly and engaging?
Poe was born in Boston, raised in Richmond, attended school in Charlottesville, and lived and worked in Baltimore, Philadelphia, and New York—the list goes on. Today, a Poe enthusiast can take something like a pilgrimage up and down the East Coast visiting the places where he lived and wrote.
At the Poe Museum, however, we emphasize that Richmond was the city of Poe’s childhood and that Poe himself considered himself a Virginian—his own words. We all understand how profoundly our early environments shape us: our imaginations, our attitudes toward social issues, and our sense of identity. The same was true for Poe.
Richmond shaped him as a thinker, as a writer, and as a young man in the early nineteenth-century United States. The city’s influence appears throughout his life and work. Richmond was the center of the American slave trade during Poe’s childhood, and John Allan enslaved domestic workers who lived in the same homes as Poe. Poe also loved the outdoors and famously swam a record-breaking stretch of the James River as an adolescent. All of these experiences shaped the man who would later be known as the “master of the macabre.”
For visitors, our collection—much of which is connected to the Allan family and Poe’s Richmond years—helps tell this story through material culture. Stories such as Poe’s river swim are particularly surprising and engaging for Richmond audiences. Recently, our Director of Education, Emma Clark, has conducted extensive research on the individuals enslaved by the Allan family. She presented a paper on her findings at the Poe Conference in Paris in 2025, and her research is now available to scholars through our website.
Events like “Unhappy Hours” and garden festivals aim to broaden engagement beyond traditional museumgoers. How do you assess whether such programming deepens appreciation for Poe versus simply entertaining?
A colleague of mine at Monticello once described this issue by imagining a graph where the y-axis represents “mission alignment” and the x-axis represents “profitability.” While these are not the only metrics for evaluating a successful program, the model helps illustrate how many nonprofits approach decision-making.
Ideally, museum programming lands in the upper-right quadrant—where audiences have an engaging or educational experience connected to Poe’s legacy and the event generates enough revenue to remain sustainable.
That said, I also believe museums have an important role beyond strictly educational programming. Museums can serve as community gathering spaces. Personally, I feel just as proud when visitors say the museum felt welcoming and enjoyable as when they leave saying, “I learned something new about Poe.”
Museums are increasingly expected to engage social issues. In what ways can The Poe Museum responsibly address themes of mental health, mortality, and trauma that permeate Poe’s work without exploiting them?
Museums are uniquely positioned to provide communities with opportunities to discuss difficult topics in good faith, without adopting unearned authority. At the museum, we discuss Poe’s struggles with substance abuse and mental health as part of our broader biographical interpretation and examine how these themes appear in his works.
We encourage questions from visitors and students and train our guides to ground their responses in factual information drawn from Poe’s life and writings rather than speculation or generalization. In this way, we can facilitate thoughtful conversations about complex topics without exploiting potentially painful subjects.
Edgar Allan Poe’s writing profoundly influenced genres like horror and detective fiction. How do you balance celebrating his popular legacy with encouraging critical exploration of the more troubling or ambiguous aspects of his life and writings?
As a subject-specific museum, it is always our mission to present a balanced and unbiased interpretation of Edgar Allan Poe’s life, works, and legacy. That means celebrating his popularity while also examining its origins, and acknowledging his genius while also recognizing his shortcomings.
Poe looms large as a cultural icon today. I enjoy exploring with visitors the difference between the mythic “Poe” and the real individual who lived only forty years in the mid-nineteenth-century United States. The tensions between Poe the historical figure, the narrators and personas within his works, and the broader cultural symbol provide fascinating opportunities for visitors to reconsider their assumptions.
In my experience, audiences are often more receptive to these complexities than museums sometimes expect.
Educational outreach, including free field trips for Title I schools, has expanded. What metrics or feedback do you use to evaluate the impact of these initiatives on students’ understanding of literature and local history?
As with all of our work at the museum, it is essential that our resources and programming respond to a want or need from our audiences. There are several ways our education team, led by Emma Clark, ensures that their resources are relevant and impactful. Many of our programs, for example, are directly aligned with Virginia’s Standards of Learning, which outline expectations for students at each grade level. We also rely heavily on educator feedback gathered through surveys, annual professional development workshops hosted at the museum, and input from advisory committees. Emma’s team also offers pre- and post-program surveys for students to complete, allowing educators to measure the tangible impact each activity has on their classroom’s knowledge base.
Behind every museum is a tension between preservation and growth. How do you decide what to conserve, what to reinterpret, and what to innovate, especially in a collection with deep historical significance?
The Poe Museum was founded over a century ago and has been a collecting institution for most of that time. As a result, our collection is large, and we are constantly cataloguing objects, confirming their condition, and assessing provenance according to the guidelines outlined in our Collections Management Policy. As the collection grows, so does the need to prioritize care for certain objects and make thoughtful decisions about the appropriate homes for others.
For example, when we redesigned the interior exhibits of the Old Stone House, we needed to clear a room that had been storing a variety of eighteenth-century furniture pieces. Many of these pieces were donated to the museum in the mid-twentieth century, had no connection to Poe, and had never been formally accessioned into the museum’s collection. We ultimately decided to give several of the pieces to fellow historical institutions that could put them to better use. Artifacts like these are often referred to as “found in collection,” and museums with long histories and large collections frequently face decisions about how best to manage them.
Making strategic decisions like this allows the museum to prioritize the care and interpretation of our most fragile and mission-critical artifacts, such as works on paper or Poe’s pocket watch. Maintaining a collection is a constant responsibility that requires careful decision-making, reassessment, and collaboration, guided by clear policies that ensure accountability and protection for all involved.
Richmond’s cultural landscape is evolving. How does The Poe Museum situate itself within broader conversations about historic preservation, gentrification, and community identity?
The Poe Museum not only stewards one of Richmond’s most historically significant structures, the Old Stone House, but it also sits within the city’s historic and complex Shockoe Bottom neighborhood. The safety of our grounds and collections is always our priority, but being a good neighbor is equally important. We recognize that the museum is woven into the cultural fabric of Shockoe Bottom and Richmond as a whole.
One of the goals in our last strategic plan was to deepen engagement with Richmond audiences and peer institutions by creating more collaborative programming and opportunities for our neighbors to visit the museum. For example, our education department created traveling pop-up exhibits about Poe that we lend to local libraries free of charge. We also offer libraries a family pass to the museum that cardholders can check out and use to visit us at no cost. Additionally, we partner with local food trucks, bands, breweries, bookstores, and other community organizations for museum events. These collaborations help ensure that the museum remains connected to its community rather than isolated from it.
The Enchanted Garden weaves Poe’s poetry into landscape design. How do you see spaces like this contributing to how people experience literature as opposed to just learning about it?
Research shows that place-based and experiential learning environments increase information retention for students. I believe this holds true for all of us. There is something special about stepping into the oasis of the Enchanted Garden and absorbing the atmosphere of tranquility and history. The grounds of the Poe Museum invite visitors to feel Poe’s words as much as they learn about them.
The Enchanted Garden is inspired by Poe’s poem “To One in Paradise,” particularly the opening stanza:
“Thou wast all to me, love,
For which my soul did pine—
A green isle in the sea, love,
A fountain and a shrine,
All wreathed with fairy fruits and flowers,
And all the flowers were mine.”
And I should add that seeing one of our two black cats strolling through an exhibit building or across the garden lawn certainly contributes to the unmistakable “Poe” atmosphere.
With museum attendance and retail sales reportedly growing post-centennial, what organizational risks or blind spots come with rapid success—especially for a century-old institution?
Rapid growth requires careful attention from leadership. Not only have our revenue and attendance increased in recent years, but our staff has also grown from a team of five to a team of eleven. As we complete the exhibit redesign and develop our next strategic plan, my focus is shifting toward stabilization and sustainability.
The greatest risk associated with rapid success is the temptation to continue expanding at a pace that outstrips our audiences. Instead, we are working intentionally to grow alongside them and ensure that our initiatives reflect their interests and needs.
As someone with experience across development, education, and museum leadership, what do you think is the biggest misconception people have about running a literary museum in the 21st century?
The modern museum leader is not simply the curator working in the archives, the docent leading school groups, or the scholar conducting research in the library. While we may occasionally play those roles, the central work of museum leadership is people management.
Most museum directors report to boards, supervise staff and volunteers, and serve diverse audiences. Meaningful change requires the support and collaboration of all these groups. I believe the museum’s recent success is largely due to the strong culture of collaboration we have cultivated at the Poe Museum.
Building that culture, especially as a new leader, requires time, vulnerability, openness to being wrong, and the conviction to stand firm when necessary. In many ways, running a museum is far more about being a skilled “people person” than many might assume.
Has there been a book, film, or work of art that significantly influenced the way you see the world or think about your work?
I wrote one of my college application essays about Bilbo Baggins, the protagonist of J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit. To this day, Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings remains one of the most formative series of books I have read. The stories captured my imagination entirely—the adventure, the strong moral framework, the intricate world-building, and the deeply sympathetic characters.
Tolkien’s works were also among the first that I remember discussing in depth with family and friends. When I watched the film adaptations as a child, it was also the first time I became aware of the creative effort required to translate a novel into a cinematic experience.
Looking at younger generations today, what gives you the greatest sense of hope, and what concerns you the most?
I am continually impressed by the confidence and insight of young people. When we host students on field trips, I love hearing their thoughts on Poe’s life and works, as well as their observations about his influence on popular culture. Younger visitors often ask the most thoughtful and surprising questions—questions that sometimes make me reconsider the familiar tour I am delivering.
At the same time, I worry that constant access to digital content is making it harder for young people to slow down and spend time with a novel. I feel this tension myself despite my best efforts to carve out time for reading. It can be difficult to step away from screens and focus on a single text for an extended period.
That said, I remain optimistic. Younger generations are actively discussing the effects of social media and screen time, and I believe some of them will lead the way in creating healthier and more balanced habits.
If you could spend a full day with any historical figure, who would you choose, and what questions would you want to ask them?
I would love to spend a day with Charlotte Brontë. Jane Eyre is one of my favorite novels. Brontë worked as both a teacher and a governess at a time when those professions were only beginning to open to women.
Mary Poovey explores the complex gender ideology surrounding female teachers and governesses in her important work Uneven Developments: The Ideological Work of Gender in Mid-Victorian England. I admire that Charlotte Brontë, during a life that lasted less than forty years, challenged nineteenth-century gender expectations not only by writing one of the most famous novels in English literature but also by pursuing a career in education.
One of my first questions to her would simply be: how did she sustain her creative inspiration and productivity as a marginalized member of 19th century English society?
If you were asked to teach a class on a subject completely unrelated to your profession, what would it be, and what would you hope students take away from it?
I would teach a class on gardening. This is somewhat related to my profession in that it is inspired by the beautiful gardens at the Poe Museum. I have always been a casual gardener, though I have never considered myself anything close to an expert. Maintaining the historic gardens at the museum—with the help of many wonderful professionals—has been an unexpectedly rewarding and educational part of my experience in this role.
I am still far from being an expert, but I have learned enough by osmosis at the museum to develop my own garden year after year. There is something incredibly satisfying about seeing your labor pay off and watching your living space gradually become more beautiful and personalized with each season. Gardening has also deepened my sense of environmental responsibility. Working with the natural world, on whatever scale, is an empowering experience that I would love to share with more people.
If you could ensure that one human value is never lost in society, which value would you choose, and why?
Curiosity—about the world, about each other, and about ourselves. Curiosity is one of the human qualities that compels us to create, to connect, and to step outside ourselves in order to engage more fully with the world around us.
It is also one of our best antidotes to hopelessness, apathy, and solipsism—the more troubling symptoms of living in a society that is hyperconnected through technology yet often deeply divided ideologically.
Humanity is facing radical changes. To name just ten: geopolitical instability, climate change, economic inequalities, technological risks, public health challenges, political polarization, resource scarcity, humanitarian crises, misinformation, and disparities in global healthcare access. If, in an imaginative exercise, you had the power to solve one of these problems, which one would you choose first and why?
In Virginia, where I live, the effects of climate change are already felt very strongly in many communities. The coastline is rapidly receding, flooding has become more common, and storms cause damage more frequently. From a preservation perspective, these developments are particularly alarming.
Jamestowne, for example, a critical historical and archaeological site that tells the story of our nation’s founding, is at risk of being largely submerged by the James River in the coming years. The Poe Museum, though it currently sits above flood level in Richmond’s Shockoe Bottom neighborhood, will likely face flood threats in the coming decades as well.
Beyond the direct harm to communities and ecosystems, climate change also threatens a devastating loss of the material culture and historic landmarks that help bind us together and tell our collective stories.
What do you believe human beings owe one another, both as individuals and as members of a global society?
Respect—for our shared humanity, for our individuality, for our connections with one another, for bodily autonomy, and for personal safety. I believe that this kind of respect grows out of humility.
Humility requires recognizing that it is impossible to fully understand every person’s experience, yet still choosing to honor their dignity.
Interviews often focus on successes. Could you share something from 2025 that did not unfold as you expected, and what that experience taught you?
We began redesigning the Poe Museum’s exhibits in 2022. I rather naively believed the project would take no more than two years. In reality, it took until late 2025 to complete most of the work, and we are still finishing a few details in 2026.
The process involved numerous unexpected setbacks, from fabrication and material delays to design changes and budget adjustments. I am proud of where the museum stands today, but the experience certainly taught me patience. It also pushed me to reflect on my own communication and collaboration style as a leader.
As a manager, I wanted staff perspectives to be heard and incorporated throughout the redesign process. At the same time, there were moments when too many voices slowed decision-making, and I had to step in and clarify direction. The experience ultimately made me a more confident decision-maker and leader, and I would approach a similar project differently in the future.
Are there any personal or professional goals you feel comfortable sharing for 2026?
Over the past four years, much of my focus at the Poe Museum has been on strengthening internal structures and processes—from staff restructuring to facilities improvements and the redesign of our exhibits.
In 2026, I hope to become more outward-facing and devote more time to sharing the museum’s progress with broader audiences. I would love to attend more conferences, speak at peer institutions, and participate in conversations like this one. It feels important to share my enthusiasm and optimism about the museum’s future.
When you imagine the final moments of your life, what kind of news would you most hope to hear, and why?
Recently, my husband’s grandfather passed away in his late nineties, surrounded by the love of his children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren. Witnessing that moment made a deep impression on me.
Ideally, we all spend our lives building a circle of people whose love and trust we share and reciprocate. To be surrounded by that kind of enduring connection at the end of one’s life seems like the greatest testament to a life well lived.